❉ Buffybot wonderful businesses, fair prices

← back

CMG Chipotle Mexican Grill

restaurant · valued with opus medium conviction · 2026-10-19

HOLD
wonderful · 83 ▟ narrow moat circle of competence: in ✓ would own for a decade trend down · -13.5% vs 200-DMA
Owner-earnings value$25.41
Price$29.89
Margin of safety -15.0%

Wonderful unit economics, but ~9% durable growth falls short of the ~12% the price already assumes.

The business

Chipotle owns and operates about 3,900 fast-casual burrito and bowl restaurants, almost all of them company-owned with no franchising. It earns money by selling a narrow, customizable menu at high volume per store, roughly $3M+ in average unit volume, through its assembly-line format and its digital/Chipotlane channels. Growth comes from opening 300+ new units a year at very high cash-on-cash returns, plus same-store sales growth from pricing and traffic.

Quality gate · 83/100

Returns on capital 30/30
Consistency 20.3/22
Margins / pricing power 7.2/16
Balance sheet 10.5/16
Cash conversion 9.8/10
Capital allocation 5.6/6
Median ROIC41.1%
Gross margin24.1%
Net debt / EBITDA2.1x
FCF conversion97%
Share count / yr-1.9%
Profitable years4/4

Moat & management

Moat ▟ narrow moat
Sourcebrand
Trajectorystable
Managementadequate

The brand is tied to 'real food' sourcing, and the simple menu gives very high throughput per store; together they produce new-unit economics competitors have not matched at scale, while purchasing scale protects margins. Restaurants have no switching costs, though, and traffic is fickle: 2025-26 comps turned negative as value perceptions and portion complaints weighed. The moat is real but must be re-earned every day in operations.

Capital allocation is disciplined: there is no funded debt (reported debt is operating leases), unit expansion is self-funded at very high returns, and the share count is falling. The weak spots are buybacks done historically at rich multiples and the post-Niccol team under Boatwright, which has not yet proven it can restore traffic momentum.

Owner-earnings inputs

Owner earnings (TTM)1.42B
Owner-earnings yield3.8%
Free-cash-flow yield4.1%
Growth used (normalized)9.0%
Market-implied growth (reverse DCF)11.8%
Terminal growth3.0%
Discount rate (hurdle)9.4%

Projected owner earnings

YrOwner earningsGrowthPV
11.55B 9.0%1.41B
21.68B 8.6%1.40B
31.82B 8.1%1.39B
41.96B 7.7%1.37B
52.10B 7.3%1.34B
62.24B 6.9%1.31B
72.39B 6.4%1.27B
82.53B 6.0%1.23B
92.67B 5.6%1.19B
102.81B 5.1%1.14B
112.94B 4.7%1.09B
123.07B 4.3%1.04B
133.19B 3.9%989.77M
143.30B 3.4%935.67M
153.39B 3.0%880.86M

Key risks

  • Sustained traffic declines as consumers trade down and pricing power hits a ceiling
  • Execution slippage under post-Niccol leadership (throughput, portions, food safety recurrence)
  • Labor and beef/avocado cost inflation compressing restaurant-level margins, plus slower unit growth as the store base saturates toward the ~7,000 North America target

Catalysts

  • Throughput and equipment initiatives (dual-sided plancha, produce slicer automation) restoring comps and margins
  • International expansion (Canada, Europe, Middle East partnerships) extending the unit growth runway beyond the US

⚠ maintenance capex ≈ min(capex, D&A), capped at FCF · Price pays for ~12%/yr owner-earnings growth over 15y (reverse DCF); model credits 9%. · Rich vs our conservative value, but a quality business is not a short — stance is WAIT for a better price, not sell.

History

DateQualityPriceValueMoSRating
2026-10-28 83 $27.98 $25.41 -9.2% HOLD
2026-10-27 83 $28.41 $25.41 -10.6% HOLD
2026-10-26 83 $27.52 $25.41 -7.7% HOLD
2026-10-23 83 $28.14 $25.41 -9.7% HOLD
2026-10-22 83 $28.12 $25.41 -9.6% HOLD
2026-10-21 83 $29.65 $25.41 -14.3% HOLD
2026-10-20 83 $29.85 $25.41 -14.9% HOLD
2026-10-19 83 $29.89 $25.41 -15.0% HOLD
2026-10-16 83 $30.58 $28.67 -6.3% HOLD
2026-10-15 83 $30.52 $28.67 -6.1% HOLD
2026-10-14 83 $30.35 $28.67 -5.5% HOLD
2026-10-13 83 $30.40 $28.67 -5.7% HOLD
2026-10-12 83 $31.59 $28.67 -9.3% HOLD
2026-10-09 83 $32.68 $28.67 -12.3% HOLD
2026-10-08 83 $30.77 $28.67 -6.8% HOLD
2026-10-07 83 $30.90 $28.67 -7.2% HOLD
2026-10-06 83 $30.85 $28.67 -7.1% HOLD
2026-10-05 83 $32.36 $28.67 -11.4% HOLD
2026-10-02 83 $32.32 $26.26 -18.8% HOLD
2026-10-01 83 $31.95 $26.26 -17.8% HOLD
2026-09-30 83 $31.88 $26.26 -17.6% HOLD
2026-09-29 83 $31.85 $26.26 -17.6% HOLD
2026-09-28 83 $31.33 $26.26 -16.2% HOLD
2026-09-25 83 $32.01 $26.26 -18.0% HOLD
2026-09-24 83 $32.71 $26.26 -19.7% HOLD
2026-09-23 83 $33.14 $26.26 -20.8% HOLD
2026-09-22 83 $33.14 $26.26 -20.8% HOLD
2026-09-21 83 $33.43 $26.26 -21.4% HOLD
2026-09-18 83 $33.51 $27.26 -18.6% HOLD
2026-09-17 83 $33.68 $27.26 -19.1% HOLD
2026-09-16 83 $34.83 $27.26 -21.7% HOLD
2026-09-15 83 $37.03 $27.26 -26.4% HOLD
2026-09-14 83 $36.20 $27.26 -24.7% HOLD
2026-09-11 83 $36.13 $27.26 -24.5% HOLD
2026-09-10 83 $36.03 $27.26 -24.3% HOLD
2026-09-09 83 $36.96 $27.26 -26.2% HOLD
2026-09-08 83 $36.96 $27.26 -26.2% HOLD
2026-09-07 83 $36.96 $27.26 -26.2% HOLD
2026-09-04 83 $37.57 $27.26 -27.4% HOLD
2026-09-03 83 $38.52 $27.26 -29.2% HOLD
2026-09-02 83 $37.51 $27.26 -27.3% HOLD
2026-09-01 83 $38.03 $27.26 -28.3% HOLD
2026-08-31 83 $38.03 $27.26 -28.3% HOLD
2026-08-28 83 $37.22 $27.26 -26.8% HOLD
2026-08-27 83 $37.34 $27.26 -27.0% HOLD
2026-08-26 83 $37.43 $27.26 -27.2% HOLD
2026-08-25 83 $38.02 $27.26 -28.3% HOLD
2026-08-24 83 $36.90 $27.26 -26.1% HOLD
2026-08-21 83 $35.29 $27.26 -22.7% HOLD
2026-08-20 83 $34.66 $27.26 -21.3% HOLD
2026-08-19 83 $33.36 $27.26 -18.3% HOLD
2026-08-18 83 $33.50 $27.26 -18.6% HOLD
2026-08-17 83 $33.50 $27.26 -18.6% HOLD
2026-08-14 83 $32.61 $27.26 -16.4% HOLD
2026-08-13 83 $32.64 $27.26 -16.5% HOLD
2026-08-12 83 $32.00 $27.26 -14.8% HOLD
2026-08-11 83 $32.14 $27.26 -15.2% HOLD
2026-08-10 83 $32.79 $27.26 -16.9% HOLD
2026-08-07 84 $33.71 $27.51 -18.4% HOLD
2026-08-06 84 $34.50 $27.51 -20.3% HOLD
2026-08-05 84 $33.82 $27.51 -18.7% HOLD
2026-08-04 84 $37.22 $27.51 -26.1% HOLD
2026-08-03 84 $37.22 $27.51 -26.1% HOLD
2026-07-31 84 $38.52 $27.51 -28.6% HOLD
2026-07-30 84 $34.24 $27.51 -19.6% HOLD
2026-07-29 84 $33.20 $27.51 -17.1% HOLD
2026-07-28 84 $33.20 $27.51 -17.1% HOLD
2026-07-27 84 $32.01 $27.51 -14.1% HOLD
2026-07-24 84 $32.01 $27.51 -14.1% HOLD
2026-07-23 84 $32.20 $27.51 -14.6% HOLD
2026-07-22 84 $33.32 $27.51 -17.4% HOLD
2026-07-21 84 $33.13 $27.51 -17.0% HOLD
2026-07-20 84 $34.44 $27.51 -20.1% HOLD
2026-07-17 84 $34.20 $27.51 -19.6% HOLD
2026-07-16 84 $34.63 $27.51 -20.6% HOLD
2026-07-15 84 $36.43 $27.51 -24.5% HOLD
2026-07-14 84 $36.63 $27.51 -24.9% HOLD
2026-07-13 84 $35.25 $27.51 -22.0% HOLD
2026-07-10 84 $34.60 $27.51 -20.5% HOLD
2026-07-09 84 $33.43 $27.51 -17.7% HOLD
2026-07-08 84 $34.35 $27.51 -19.9% HOLD
2026-07-07 84 $33.98 $27.51 -19.0% HOLD
2026-07-06 84 $35.39 $27.51 -22.3% HOLD
2026-07-03 84 $35.39 $27.51 -22.3% HOLD
2026-07-02 84 $35.00 $27.51 -21.4% HOLD
2026-06-26 84 $32.28 $24.94 -22.8% SELL
2026-06-25 84 $31.69 $24.94 -21.3% SELL
2026-06-24 84 $30.95 $23.93 -22.7% SELL
2026-06-23 84 $30.95 $25.98 -16.1% SELL